Tax compliance in cryptocurrency remains perilously low due to a confluence of factors, primarily the complexity of regulations, the absence of third-party reporting, and the inherent anonymity of digital transactions. Many investors are not fully aware of their tax obligations, which the IRS struggles to enforce effectively. As cryptocurrency adoption escalates, the challenges of tracking and reporting holdings increase, further complicating compliance. Thus, despite growing scrutiny from tax authorities, a significant portion of potential tax revenue continues to elude the system.
Overview of Cryptocurrency and Taxation
Cryptocurrency, including popular assets like Bitcoin and Ethereum, operates within a framework that is both innovative and challenging from a tax perspective. The IRS has updated tax forms to include questions specifically about digital assets, indicating a shift in focus toward ensuring compliance in this rapidly evolving market. As cryptocurrency trading grows, the need for clear guidelines becomes increasingly pressing.
The Importance of Tax Compliance in the Crypto Market
Ensuring tax compliance is critical not just for revenue generation but also for the legitimacy of the crypto market. The absence of compliance can lead to a loss of trust among investors and hinder the broader acceptance of digital currencies. Regulatory bodies are now more than ever focused on enhancing compliance measures, which could influence the future of crypto market dynamics.
Key Reasons for Low Tax Compliance
Complexity of Crypto Tax Laws
The intricacies of crypto tax laws can be bewildering for investors. Unlike traditional assets, the rules surrounding cryptocurrencies are still being developed, leading to confusion and misinterpretations regarding tax liabilities. According to research, when there is no third-party income information, tax compliance can drop to as low as 55% (TIGTA Report). This lack of clarity often results in investors inadvertently falling afoul of regulations.
Lack of Third-Party Reporting
Another significant hurdle in achieving higher compliance rates is the absence of third-party reporting. Many cryptocurrency exchanges do not provide necessary tax reporting documents, complicating the process for investors looking to accurately report their earnings. This challenge is exacerbated by the decentralized nature of cryptocurrencies, which allows users to transact without central oversight, as highlighted in a study on the current state of crypto tax compliance.
Anonymity and Decentralization of Transactions
The inherent anonymity associated with digital currencies adds another layer of difficulty for tax authorities. While this feature appeals to many investors, it also complicates the IRS's efforts to enforce tax compliance. The pseudonymous nature of transactions means that tracking and verifying individual transactions can be a daunting task for regulators, as noted in various studies on the subject.
Awareness and Understanding Among Investors
Education Gaps in the Cryptocurrency Community
Education is a crucial factor in improving tax compliance. Many investors lack a solid understanding of their tax obligations when it comes to cryptocurrency trading. The misconception that holding cryptocurrency does not incur tax liabilities has persisted, leading to widespread non-compliance. As the market evolves, there is an urgent need for educational resources to bridge these gaps.
Common Misunderstandings about Tax Responsibilities
Common misunderstandings about tax responsibilities can lead to significant pitfalls for investors. Many believe that unless they liquidate their holdings, they do not incur any tax obligations. However, the reality is that trading between different cryptocurrencies can also trigger taxable events, which many investors are unaware of.
Regulatory Challenges Faced by Authorities
Enforcement Difficulties for the IRS
The IRS faces unique challenges in enforcing tax compliance within the crypto market. With limited visibility into transactions and a reliance on self-reporting, tracking unreported gains becomes immensely difficult. The growing complexity of cryptocurrency products, such as wrapped tokens and decentralized finance, further complicates the enforcement landscape.
Proposed Changes to Enhance Compliance
Proposed changes to enhance compliance include stricter reporting requirements and increased scrutiny of crypto transactions. As the IRS allocates additional resources towards enforcement, the landscape for tax compliance is likely to shift, potentially leading to higher compliance rates in the future.
The Future of Crypto Tax Compliance
Trends and Predictions for Tax Regulation in Crypto
Looking ahead, the regulatory landscape for cryptocurrency is expected to evolve significantly. Tax authorities worldwide are beginning to implement stricter regulations, with the aim of capturing the substantial tax revenue that is currently escaping due to non-compliance. This trend is likely to accelerate as cryptocurrency adoption continues to rise.
Impact of Technological Advances on Compliance
Technological advances may also play a pivotal role in improving tax compliance within the cryptocurrency sector. While many of the current solutions are not up to the task, enhanced tracking tools and reporting technologies could provide better oversight and facilitate compliance for both investors and tax authorities alike.
Conclusion and Final Thoughts
The Necessity for Increased Compliance
In conclusion, the necessity for increased compliance in the cryptocurrency sector cannot be overstated. As the market continues to grow, the implications of non-compliance become more severe, affecting not just individual investors but the integrity of the entire financial system.
Encouraging Responsible Investment in Digital Assets
Encouraging responsible investment in digital assets is crucial for fostering a sustainable and trustworthy crypto market. As investors become more educated about their tax obligations, the potential for improved compliance and trust in the crypto ecosystem will likely follow.
Sources
-
2 More Reasons Why Crypto Tax Compliance Is Increasingly Difficult
https://www.forbes.com/sites/digital-assets/2023/11/28/two-more-reasons-why-crypto-tax-compliance-is-increasingly-difficult/
Stated another way the reporting requirements that are being solidified are going to either create larger tax liabilities than anticipated or at the very least much larger workloads than originally thought. Tax season is coming, and no matter what aspect of crypto is looked at, it is shaping up to be an intense next year or so for investors, practitioners, and entrepreneurs in the space. [...] Wrapped tokens, decentralized finance options, staked crypto, and the non-fungible token subsets of crypto have only made the tax conversations more complex and time-consuming. As the IRS continues to prioritize tax revenues associated with crypto investors, proposed changes are set to amplify these pre-existing issues. [...] With all of the drama that has recently surrounded the crypto sector, most recently the resignation of CZ from Binance and the associated penalties and monitoring measures that will hamstring the firm going forward, tax compliance can seem like a tame concept by comparison. After all the crypto tax conversation has never been terribly straightforward for investors of any sizes, and more recent developments in the crypto sector have only made it more complicated.
-
Understanding the Heated Debate Over Cryptocurrencies and Tax ...
https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/understanding-heated-debate-over-cryptocurrencies-and-tax-compliance
It makes sense for Congress to ensure cryptocurrency investors pay taxes the same way as holders of other financial assets. But the decentralized nature of blockchain technology that intrigues investors and futurists also makes tax compliance hard.
-
Crypto-assets And The Tax Compliance Challenge - IFC Review
https://www.ifcreview.com/articles/2025/february/crypto-assets-and-the-tax-compliance-challenge/
limited government oversight. Currently, with no third-party reporting and an increasing adoption of crypto-assets, regulators are facing an unprecedented challenge. Tax authorities worldwide struggle to track crypto holdings and enforce tax compliance, relying mostly on self-reporting. As a result, it is assumed that a substantial amount of crypto gains is escaping the tax system. [...] Unlike traditional financial assets, cryptocurrencies operate within a decentralised and pseudonymous framework. Transactions are recorded on a blockchain, offering transparency at the transaction level but without revealing users’ identities. This pseudonymity provides some secrecy level and introduces significant challenges for tax compliance. The rapid growth of crypto markets has created an expansive financial ecosystem where assets can be held, traded, or transferred across borders with [...] suggests that the bottom 50 per cent are more involved in crypto than traditional wealth. It is interesting to see that crypto is more appealing to the bottom 50 per cent as it could be a way to make more gains. In short, while crypto wealth is concentrated among the wealthy, it has attracted those in lower wealth brackets, giving them a relatively larger share than they hold in traditional assets.
-
What Are the Main Challenges of Crypto Tax Compliance? - IVIX
https://www.ivix.ai/post/what-are-the-main-challenges-of-crypto-tax-compliance
Tax authorities face two main challenges in driving compliance in crypto: reporting and accurately calculating cost basis. These challenges are mainly due to the use of unregulated exchanges. Regulated and Unregulated Exchanges Exchanges allow investors to exchange cryptocurrencies for traditional currencies. They are similar to stock exchanges, but are not currently regulated by the SEC. [...] We found that 80-90% of the value of cryptocurrency received is received via trading on crypto exchanges, while only 2% of crypto transactions involve making purchases. Given this, we believe capital gains incurred by trading on exchanges and marketplaces offer the greatest return on investment in compliance. What Are the Challenges of Crypto Tax Compliance? [...] As we discussed in an earlier blog post, that trading volume translates to significant potential tax revenue. But the crypto market is an opaque and technically complex system, representing a new obstacle for tax authorities in the ongoing challenge of the shadow economy.Â
-
The current state of Crypto Tax Compliance - Ledgible
https://ledgible.io/the-current-state-of-crypto-tax-compliance/
At that time, the general public and the IRS were not well educated on how crypto worked. The belief was that if the holder of crypto does not liquidate the crypto, there is no taxable event. And if brokers did report taxable events, it was across 1099 MISC, K, INT, or B and did not include cost basis, gross payments, income or proceeds. [...] “We go far enough back and a lot of people thought that buying and trading crypto was anonymous and I think a lot of us know that it’s probably not true,” said Nik Fahrer, Director at Forvis Mazars, US, ranked among the largest public accounting and consulting firms. “Overall, there was a lack of taxation knowledge in the space.” [...] The current state of Crypto Tax Compliance When crypto emerged onto the market, it wasn’t well known and had little regulatory oversight. However, over the years crypto has grown in popularity and its use as an investment and financial service, the public has invested in crypto and the IRS has taken notice.
-
[PDF] Virtual Currency Tax Compliance Enforcement Can Be Improved
https://www.tigta.gov/sites/default/files/reports/2024-07/2024300030fr_0.pdf
tax returns to ensure that taxpayers are accurately reporting their income generated from virtual currencies. When there is income information reporting from third parties, tax compliance exceeds 90 percent; however, when there is no third-party income information tax compliance is 55 percent.3 For some taxpayers, the anonymity has been part of virtual currency’s appeal, and the anonymity of virtual currencies complicates the IRS’s enforcement efforts. For other taxpayers that purchased virtual [...] for taxpayers, creating taxable consequences each time the virtual currency is used as a medium of exchange.2 Due to the anonymity of virtual currency transactions, the IRS does not always have a clear window into taxpayers’ transactions, and the trading platforms do not generally provide information reporting documents to the IRS. Without information reporting documents, the IRS has been unable to use some of its enforcement tools to match reported virtual currency-related income to taxpayers’ [...] currency on various platforms and moved among different digital wallets, determining taxable gains may be problematic, even when the taxpayers want to be tax compliant.4 While all cryptocurrencies are virtual currencies, not all virtual currencies are cryptocurrencies. Both virtual currency and cryptocurrencies fall under the umbrella of digital assets, and both use cryptographic protocols to secure transactions recorded on publicly or privately available decentralized ledgers, called
-
Crypto Taxes: The Complete Guide (2025) - CoinLedger
https://coinledger.io/guides/crypto-tax
Over the past several years, the IRS has aggressively cracked down on cryptocurrency tax compliance issues. Itâs updated the main US income tax form (1040) to include a question that every US taxpayer must answer under penalty of perjury: As cryptocurrency adoption accelerates, itâs likely that weâll see more cryptocurrency tax audits and tax prosecutions. How do you lower your crypto taxes? [...] Cryptocurrency exchanges like Coinbase, Binance, and others often do not have the ability to provide their users with accurate capital gains and losses tax reports. This is not a fault of the exchanges themselves, it is simply a product of the unique characteristics of cryptocurrenciesânamely their transferability.
-
Red Alert: Why You Need to Fix Your Crypto Taxes Right Now
https://gordonlaw.com/learn/red-alert-fix-crypto-taxes-now/
It’s a new level of scrutiny on top of an already urgent matter. Surveys indicate that the majority of crypto investors in the United States have not reported digital assets on their taxes. And every single one of those investors is at risk of a tax audit or a criminal investigation. [...] As a part of the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022, the IRS received an $80 billion annual budget increase. The influx of cash for the agency will allow it to dedicate even more time and resources to focus on auditing large corporations and wealthy taxpayers, as well as enforcing cryptocurrency users’ tax compliance. The IRS has stated explicitly that “expanded work on digital assets is one of the priority areas where the IRS will focus” in using those funds to target “very low-hanging fruit.”
